Skip to main content

Table 1 Scoping review sources, ordered by country and lead author

From: Addressing female genital mutilation in Europe: a scoping review of approaches to participation, prevention, protection, and provision of services

Lead author, year

Design

Participation

Prevention

Protection

Provision

Communities

Belgium (1)

 Dieleman, 2010 [14]

Focus groups/interviewsa

x

x

x

x

Djibouti, Guinea, Somalia

 Finland (1)

Johansson, 2008 [20]

Project report

x

x

  

Somalia

France (9)

 Andro, 2010 [3]

Qualitative interviews

   

x

Guinea, Mali, Senegal,

 Andro, 2009 [2]

Qualitative interviews

 

x

 

x

(as above)

 Johnsdotter, 2009a [24] Johnsdotter, 2009b [25]

Cohort study

   

x

 

 Grunvald, 2008

Secondary research

 

x

 

x

 

 Le Roux, 2009

Qualitative interviews

 

x

 

x

 

 Martin, 2007 [32] Wehenkel, 2007 Njierboer, 2010

Secondary research

 

x

x

  

 Kool, 2014b

Secondary research

  

x

  

Germany (1)

      

 Behrendt, 2011 [6]

Qualitative interviewsa

x

x

 

x

Ghana, Nigeria, Togo

Italy (2)

      

 Caroppo, 2014

Survey

  

x

x

 

 Turrilazzi, 2007

Secondary research

  

x

  

Netherlands (2)

 Vloeberghs, 2012 [47] Vloeberghs, 2011 [46]

Qualitative interviewsa

x

 

x

x

Eritrea, Ethiopia, Sierra Leone, Somalia, Sudan,

 

Qualitative interviews

x

x

x

 

(as above)

Norway (4)

 Gele, 2012a [19] Gele, 2012b [20] Lien & Schulz, 2014 [30]

Focus groups

x

x

  

Somalia

 

Focus groups

 

x

  

Somalia

 

Qualitative interviews

 

x

x

 

Somalia, Gambia, Eritrea, Kenya

 Schulz, 2013

Qualitative interviews

x

x

  

Somalia, Gambia

Spain (3)

      

 Azkona, 2015

Proceedings paper

 

x

   

 Kaplan, 2009a

Survey of professionals

  

x

x

 

 Kaplan, 2009b

Project description

x

x

   

Sweden (6)

 Isman, 2013

Qualitative interviews

x

x

  

Somalia

 Foldes, 2012 [23]a

Qualitative interviews

x

   

Eritrea, Ethiopia

 

Literature and case review

  

x

  

 Litorp, 2008

Survey/clinical review

x

  

x

Eritrea, Somalia

 Lundberg, 2008

Qualitative interviews

x

x

 

x

Eritrea

 Widmark, 2010

Qualitative interviews

   

x

 

Switzerland (2)

      

 Abdulcadir, 2014 [1]

Review of clinical files

   

x

 

 Renteria, 2008

Literature review, clinical case studies

 

x

 

x

 

UK (22)

 Bindel, 2014 [8]

Survey

 

x

x

  

 Brown, 2013 [10]

Participatory action research

x

x

   

 Creighton, 2010 [13]

Report

 

x

 

x

 

 Dustin, 2010 [10] Esmee Fairbairn Foundation, 2013 [16]

Secondary research

x

 

x

  

 Gordon, 2007

Clinical review/interviews

   

x

 
 

Secondary research

  

x

  

 Guine, 2007 [21] Hemmings, 2011 [22]

Reporta

x

x

   

 Hussein, 2008

Observational data

x

  

x

Somalia

 Jones, 2010

Qualitative interviews/ survey

   

x

 

 Lavender, 2009 [27]

Survey

 

x

 

x

 
 

Qualitative interviews

x

x

 

x

Somalia

 Levac, 2010 [33]

Literature review & stakeholder interviews

 

x

 

x

 

 Liao, 2013 [29]

Qualitative participatory researcha

x

x

  

Eritrea, Somalia, Sudan

 Moore, 2014 [33] Norman, 2009 [35] Paliwal, 2014 RCM, 2013 [37] Relph, 2013 [39] Safari, 2013 [40] Strauss, 2009 Zaidi, 2007 Zenner, 2013

Retrospective case analysis

  

x

x

 
 

Questionnaire

 

x

 

x

 
 

Qualitative interviews

   

x

Somalia

 

Qualitative interviews

   

x

Somalia

 

Questionnaire

   

x

 
 

Retrospective clinical audit

   

x

 
 

Literature review/workshops

 

x

x

x

 
 

PEER, project report, qualitative interviewsa

x

x

   
 

Conference report

x

x

x

x

 

EU-wide (8)

 Berg, 2013 [7]

Literature review

x

X

   

 EIGE, 2013 [17]

Literature review

x

X

x

x

 

 Krasa, 2009 [31]

Literature review

 

x

x

x

 

 Leye, 2009a [34]

Survey/workshops

   

x

 

 Leye, 2009b

Questionnaires, workshops, expert reports

  

x

  

 Leye, 2009c

Literature review

 

X

x

  

 Leye, 2007

Questionnaire

 

X

x

  

 Novak, 2013

Statistical analysis

 

X

x

  

Global (9)

 Balogun, 2012 [5]

Literature review

   

x

 

 Boyle, 2010

Secondary researcha

x

X

x

  

 Costello, 2013 [11]

Literature review

x

X

x

x

 

 Cottingham, 2009 [12]

Secondary research

 

X

x

  

 Kontoyannis, 2010

Literature review

 

X

 

x

 

 Lien, 2013 [30]

Qualitative

x

x

   

 Mulongo, 2014

Literature review

   

x

 

 NMHES, 2009

Report

x

x

x

  

 Reig Alcaraz, 2014

Literature review

x

x

x

x

 
 

totals

N = 28

N = 43

N = 29

N = 40

N = 20

  1. NB: aIncluded participatory research methods; bIncluded the Netherlands